Compare the cost of buying a real Christmas tree every year with an artificial tree that lasts years – and find the year the artificial tree pays for itself.
By TanLabs Editorial Team · Reviewed: page results cross-checked against the free spreadsheet · Last updated · Runs in your browser – nothing you type is sent anywhere
With real tree price this year $100, real tree price rise per year 3%, real tree extras per year: stand water, delivery, disposal $15, artificial tree price $250, artificial tree lifespan 10 years, artificial tree extras per year: storage, bulbs $5, years to compare 10:
Artificial is cheaper by $996.39 over 10 years
The artificial tree pays for itself in year 3 · real total $1,296.39 vs artificial $300.00
Change any number above – the result, chart and table update instantly. Use Copy link to save or share your exact scenario.
Real tree cost in year k = this year's price × (1 + yearly rise)^(k − 1) + yearly extras. Artificial: the tree price is paid in year 1 and again after each lifespan, plus yearly extras. Break-even is the first year the artificial running total is no higher than the real one.
Formula source: Yearly price growing at a constant rate (compound growth) compared with a one-off artificial tree cost; tree facts from the National Christmas Tree Association. SEC Investor.gov – compound interest formula and calculator · National Christmas Tree Association – real tree facts
Written and checked by the TanLabs Editorial Team · Last updated
$100 real tree rising 3% a year with $15 extras, vs a $250 artificial tree replaced every 10 years with $5 a year extras:
| After | Real trees (total) | Artificial (total) | Real minus artificial |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | $115.00 | $255.00 | -$140.00 |
| Year 2 | $233.00 | $260.00 | -$27.00 |
| Year 3 | $354.09 | $265.00 | $89.09 |
| Year 5 | $605.91 | $275.00 | $330.91 |
| Year 10 | $1,296.39 | $300.00 | $996.39 |
| Year 15 | $2,084.89 | $575.00 | $1,509.89 |
In this example the artificial tree pays for itself in year 3 – but the advantage resets when it wears out and must be replaced. Cheaper artificial trees with short lifespans can cost more than real ones.
Prices vary by size, species and region. Check a local farm or lot – a 6–7 ft tree commonly costs somewhere between $80 and $130 in the US.
Many last 6–10 years; better-quality trees with hinged branches can last longer if they are stored dry and flat-packed.
Studies disagree on details, but an artificial tree generally needs to be reused for many years to match a locally grown real tree that is recycled.
Often right after Christmas, when stores clear seasonal stock at deep discounts.
Prices have generally risen with growing costs and limited supply; enter your own yearly rise.
It saves untangling lights, but if a section of lights fails it can be hard to fix, which can shorten the tree's useful life.
Sources: National Christmas Tree Association – real tree facts